The match winner in the first knockout round of the Papa John's Trophy against Stevenage when he saved three successive penalties, Dean Bouzanis repeated the trick in sensational circumstances at the DW Stadium to send Sutton to Wembley for the first time in 41 years, saving twice in the penalty shootout as well as converting a spot kick of his own as U's won 7-6 on penalties after a 1-1 draw.
The 320 travelling supporters were sent in to ecstasy as Bouzanis dived to turn away Wigan captain Tendayi Darikwa's penalty, having also saved Wigan's first penalty from Max Power, and then converted U's seventh penalty with as impressive a spot kick as any in a high quality shootout.
U's matched the League One promotion chasers throughout the game, leading through Will Randall's 29th minute goal before being pegged back by James McClean's vicious strike ten minutes later, and then missing several chances early in the second half before Wigan manager Leam Richardson, who had changed the entire starting line-up from Saturday's league win against Wimbledon, brought on three of his main players midway through the second half, after which U's were on the back foot but held the home team at bay to set up the shootout.
U's team selection involved less major surgery, Harry Beautyman remaining in midfield as Kenny Davis failed to recover from the injury that forced him off on Saturday, and Donovan Wilson and Will Randall replacing Richie Bennett and Enzio Boldewijn, and in an untidy first quarter of the game it was Wigan who had the first real chance as a mistake by Louis John on the halfway line allowed James McClean to send Jamie McGrath through, but he rolled his shot just the wrong side of the post as Bouzanis came out.
Sutton gradually asserted themselves, though, the home defence put under pressure when in possession, and so nearly went in front when, from the first U's corner of the night, Joe Kizzi headed against the foot of the post from Randall's delivery. Nine minutes later, though, U's had the lead when a free kick from Bouzanis was headed on by Omar Bugiel and expertly laid off by Wilson for Randall, who controlled the ball with a hint of unintentional handball before rolling it past goalkeeper Jamie Jones.
Wigan responded well to going behind with McClean, one of three players eligible to play despite being suspended in the league, their biggest threat and he cut one cross low in from the left that ran all the way through to Tom Bayliss, whose shot was too high. Moments later, though, McClean had equalised when Tom Pearce, again with an equal hint of an equally unintentional handball, controlled a crossfield pass on the left and played the ball inside to McClean, whose thumping drive gave Bouzanis no chance at his near post.
Having finished the first half under pressure, U's turned things round early in the second half and could have retaken the lead on several occasions. Kizzi again came close to scoring for the fourth game in a row when David Ajiboye rolled the ball back from the by-line in to his path, but mis-hit his shot and allowed Jones to save, while Randall had the goalkeeper diving to his left to keep out a trademark curling shot from the edge of the penalty area, and Bugiel volleyed over from Wilson's cross before being denied by the legs of the keeper from a narrow angle after pressure from Ajiboye and Wilson had forced a defensive error.
The triple substitution changed the game, though, and U's saw little of the ball for the last twenty minutes. The defence was organised, though, and Wigan had to be patient to try and create any openings. Josh Magennis glanced a header over from a McClean cross, and Bouzanis made a good low save from McGrath, but for their overwhelming possession advantage the home side created few other clear cut chances, Power sending one superb cross in from the right that no one could convert, and Darikwa putting the ball straight in to Bouzanis's hands from a good position after beating Beautyman on the right.
Referee James Bell blew the final whistle before Wigan could take one last corner, and in front of the U's fans Craig Eastmond opened the shootout convincingly before Bouzanis dived to his right to save from Power. Jones then kept out Beautyman's effort allowing Graham Shinnie to level things up, after which neither keeper got close to anything, Rob Milsom, Ben Goodliffe, Richie Bennett, Enzio Boldewijn and Bouzanis all taking impressive penalties for U's matched by Will Keane, McClean, Magennis, Gwion Edwards and McGrath. John made no mistake either from U's eighth penalty, but Bouzanis again went to his right to deny Darikwa, sparking wild celebrations behind him as U's players sprinted from the halfway line to join in the celebrations. U's are going to Wembley!
Sutton: D Bouzanis, J Kizzi, R Milsom, C Eastmond, B Goodliffe, L John, D Ajiboye, D Wilson(sub E Boldewijn 75), O Bugiel(sub R Bennett 78), H Beautyman, W Randall(sub R Korboa 83). Subs n/u S Nelson, B Wyatt, C Rowe, K Kouassi. Booked: Ajiboye
Wigan: J Jones, K Watts, T Pearce(sub W Keane 65), T Darikwa, J Kerr, G Shinnie, T Bayliss(sub G Edwards 65), J McGrath, J Magennis, G Massey(sub M Power 65), J McClean. Subs n/u B Amos, J Bennett, C Tilt, C Sze. Booked: Magennis, Shinnie
Referee: James Bell
Attendance: 6,541 (320 away)