Sutton will be at home to either Barnsley or Horsham in the second round of the Emirates FA Cup.
The sides drew 3-3 at Oakwell on Friday night and will replay at Horsham's Camping World Community Stadium next week. Horsham led 2-1 at one stage but earned their replay with an equaliser nine minutes from time.
Barnsley are currently in fifth place in League One, while Horsham are eighth in the Isthmian League Premier Division, although with games in hand over all the sides above them.
The tie will be played over the weekend of December 2/3.